• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

New York Bagelry: Authentic NYC-Style Bagels and Sandwiches in Reading, PA

In the heart of Reading, PA, New York Bagelry stands out as a must-visit spot for bagel lovers. With a wide array of flavors, from classic to seasonal, their bagels are always fresh and delicious, earning high praise from loyal customers. The friendly staff and prompt service provide a welcoming experience, whether you choose to dine in or grab your meal on the go. While some customers note minor inconsistencies in bagel shapes, the overall quality and taste make up for it. Offering a variety of menu options, including breakfast and lunch sandwiches, as well as catering services, New York Bagelry truly lives up to its reputation as a top-notch bagel shop in the area.

New York Bagelry at a glance

  • Address 2720 Penn Ave Reading, PA 19609
  • Phone (610) 678-6420
  • Restaurant type Bagel shop .

Photos & Gallery

New York Bagelry: Reviews & Ratings

EDVARD PHILIPSON
5

The best NY bagels in Berks County! Many varieties and freshly made!

Georgi Ekimov
5

I recently drove by New York Bagelry while traveling from NJ. Although I usually don’t make stops on the road, the inviting atmosphere on a Sunday morning made me turn around and visit. Upon entering, I was warmly welcomed by a couple of young ladies. I ordered the evening special, which included a classic sandwich and a coffee. Within a few minutes, I received my hot bagel sandwich and a cup for coffee. They offered a wide variety of fresh coffee, and I chose French vanilla, my favorite. I sat in the clean and pleasant dining room, enjoying my sandwich in front of the TV. The sandwich was great, but the French vanilla coffee was exceptional—the best I’ve ever had in the USA. Thank you, New York Bagelry, for the excellent service and for making my day. I will definitely stop by again if I’m ever in the area. Best of luck!

Jeff Lee
5

"Best Bagels" in Reading-Lancaster area. Great bagel/ coffee/ breakfast/ lunch spot. 20+ Bagel choices ...plus 6-10 homemade cream cheese options. Breakfast and Lunch menu. Always friendly service. You need to check-out this local hidden gem. Thank you!

Heather Quay
5

I love their BLT with mayo on a plain toasted bagel. They give such a good portion of bacon! It’s one of my favorite sandwiches.

Shannon foreman
5

First time here, I love the variety of bagels on hand, homemade too!! I ordered a spinach bagel with sausage, egg and cheese. It was very delicious! I love spinach so maybe add some more in the bagel but otherwise I'd order it again. My husband got a bacon, egg, and cheese on a jalapeño bagel. His mouth was on fire! The place is clean and well kept. Staff is friendly, polite.

Marc Fulmer
5

Fresh New York style bagels and homemade cream cheese spreads. Delicious muffins too. You may have to wait a while, though, because the drive though gets busy and takes a while to move through.

Supakij Khomvilai
5

Really good bagel you have to try ! Opened early in the morning and fresh bagel made daily. Cream cheese are also good. I had different menu for 2 times visited and everything area so good. Staffs are helpful and friendly. Hot coffee bar and fountain are available. Credit card accepted and they have drive thru which so popular especially in the morning. Enjoy!

Kim P
5

Variety of flavors of bagels and cream cheeses to choice from. Breakfast and deli meat and cheese bagels available. They do not skimp on the cream cheese. They wrapped the bagel in parchment paper then in foil for To Go order. Will definitely stop there again.

Location

  • New York Bagelry
    New York Bagelry
    2720 Penn Ave Reading, PA 19609 Hotline: (610) 678-6420
New York Bagelry: A Taste of Authentic NY Bagels in Reading, PA

If you're looking for a taste of authentic New York-style bagels in Reading, PA, look no further than New York Bagelry. Located at 2720 Penn Ave, this bagel haven offers a variety of mouthwatering options that are sure to satisfy your cravings.

From breakfast sandwiches like the Taylor Ham Bagel to lunch sandwiches like the Italian Bagels, there is something for everyone at New York Bagelry. Their bagel bundles, including 14 bagels and cream cheese, are perfect for sharing with friends and family.

Customer reviews rave about the freshness and deliciousness of the food at New York Bagelry. Jenn A. mentions that the prices are incredibly reasonable for the high-quality food you receive, while Dstrock73 appreciates the superior taste of the bagels compared to other places in the area.

Service at New York Bagelry is always prompt and professional, making it a go-to spot for those looking for a quick and satisfying meal. Whether you dine in or take your meal to go, you can always count on a great experience at New York Bagelry.

So, if you're craving a delicious, authentic NY-style bagel in Reading, be sure to stop by New York Bagelry. You won't be disappointed!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Has drive-through
    • In-store pick-up for online orders
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards